Tuesday, 20 March 2012

Freedom of Expression and Religious Sentiment


Debate is again assuming importance in relation to Freedom of expression and Religious Sentiment:
Following questions may be asked:

1. whether religious sentiments is hurdle in the progressive road of freedom of idea, speech and expression?
2. whether religious sentiments are itself part of freedom of expression?
3. what about clash of rights?
4. whether freedom can be absolute? if not, what are the reasonable restrictions? what are the justifications to  support reasonable restrictions?
5. What are the basic elements of "reasonable restrictions"? Is is country specific or universal? whether it derive validity from prevailing political notion and setup; and culture?
6. whether imposing Universal Value System is not against the freedom of expression?
7. how to solve clash of rights? whether particular value system may help to determine? whether Universal Value System may help to determine?
8. How to strike a balance between domestic notion of value and universal notion of value (that may be used to solve issues)?
9. Is there any "basic structure" of rights?
10. How freedom of expression (particularly criticizing sentiments) help the society to grow?
11. what is the co-relation between development, progressiveness and freedom of ideas? whether religious sentiments is hurdle in ways of progress? What is progress anyway? How freedom of expression like criticism of basic fundamental values (for e.g. prohibition of alcohol, prohibition of unnatural sex) help society to grow?

Monday, 23 January 2012

Freedom without Regulation: A Journey from Misunderstanding to Misdeeds


28.01.2012



Freedom without Regulation: A Journey from Misunderstanding to Misdeeds

"Let not make heroes out of those people who are banned", were the words of one of the authors at the same event, who further added that, "everyone has right to condemn things which they find offending". This remark very timely highlights what needed most- every party has right to freedom, even against freedom. Lets imagine a world where everybody is having "unfettered" right of freedom of expression. What would happen? Chaos in democratic fraternity? Communalizations of society? Instability in the whole law and order machinery? State of emergency? May be agreed. But present bunch of “progressive writers” and their supporters think otherwise! 

A National daily mentioned its opinion under titled, "A National Shame", describing the whole phenomenon of Jaipur Literature Festival, few days back.  I wonder and surprise; because it is advocating essentially "unfettered" freedom of speech,  overlooking completely the another and equally important side- restriction but reasonable. State Govt.’s ban on controversial writer is being condemned everywhere in the name of freedom of expression of speech, without looking at inherent policy and rationale behind the public order. 

Constitution of India provides freedom of speech as one of the most celebrated and fundamental human right. Everybody has right to speech and expression, but not whatever a person wishes to do or say. It further says that State may impose reasonable restrictions on the ground of "Sovereignty and Integrity of India", "Security of the State”, "Public Order" etc. Apart from this Indian Penal Code also contain various Sections to this effect (Sections 153A, 295, 295A, 296 etc.). This legal rationale is based on well founded and progressive jurisprudence, developed and observed over a period of thousands of years. No civilized society ever went against this well founded jurisprudence in the interest of whole society. After all "Collective national interest is more than sum of individual interests", the underlying basis of all reasonable restrictions. Even the highest Court of Land upheld these restrictions. 

Nobody has right, in the interest of whole society, to hurt the religious sentiments of any group, assured and guaranteed by Constitution, mentioned in the same chapter of Fundamental Rights, though, again with reasonable restrictions. And what if these two right clashes with the "progress of society"? It definitely needs to go back to the principle of harmonious construction, giving the State and Judiciary have power to determine the clash of interests. As the Law and Order is State Subject, the actions of State is perfectly justified. Nobody is stopping the "aggrieved party" to go to the Court. This is how democracy works, an ideal condition. Nobody is taking law into their own hands. 

Now comes the concept of secularism and the way its meanings were given new shades by the same group of the so called progressive people. It’s even argued, criminally, that India is moving on the verge of democratic demise, because secularism is not observed. What a fallacy! Again secularism is misunderstood. Secularism means every group of people will have right to profess its religion or ideology, and State will follow the policy of Sarva Dharma Shambhav. But it is also the duty of the State to save secularism and protect citizens against any attempt which may try to ruin the social fabric. How? Curbing the freedom of expression (of religion) or freedom of expression (which goes against the secularism). A child will give better answer. A child is innocent and impartial. Child is open to all religion maintaining their own. They enjoy the joy and become the part of same fabric. Secularism essentially lies in the notion of tolerance and respect for every religion.

In the concerned State, resorting to law and order problem is just means, not an end. It should do more. It is also argued that there is no such law which bans a controversial author coming to India, because imposed ban is on book (only import ban under Custom Act, 1962). Then, how can a State Govt. may stop a controversial author? The answer is again same: in the name of maintaining law and order. Now it would be exaggeration to say that, in the name of law and order, State may do "whatever it thinks fit". The requirement here is balanced approach. 

As far as role of media is concerned, recently Justice M. Katju highlighted very well role and duties of media. Nothing much to add here. It has been seen that it remains averse to basic understanding of law and order, most of the time. Very few would come up with balanced approach. More ridiculously, this whole exercise (of ban) is being seen in the context of upcoming elections in few States, by some political pundits. Presenting one view and negating other-side has become its agenda, it appears, in many cases. Nobody knows why, except God. 

Whether freedom of expression (from the point of controversial author) is greater than freedom of speech and expression (that includes the freedom to profess to one’s own religion as freedom of expression etc.)? Is there any hierarchy among many form of freedoms of speech and expression? Can “progressive” thought eradicate or remove every piece of legislation which mentions reasonable restrictions? Even if it becomes able to do so in form, it can never do in spirit, for sure. Conclusion: if collective interest is not observed, it will lead to such a chaos that would be unmanageable. No freedom and progress can be achieved and realized without reasonable restrictions on fundamental rights. Moreover, these so called progressive thoughts appear "progressive less" but "regressive more". This whole ideological deed is indeed a journey from misunderstanding to misdeeds. "Let’s wait and watch", is good idea?



Meraj Ahmad





Monday, 26 December 2011

EK BAAT

Baat nikli aur door talak chali....par baat thi kya? Kin logon ne ye baat shuru ki? Kya usko itni door jaane ki zarurat thi? Kaun baton ki zaruraton ko tay karta hai? Kitne logon apni saari himmat aur zindagi laga di usko sahi ya galat kehne me? In baaton se humne kya khoya aur kya paaya? Kis ko faida hua aur kis ko nuksaan? Kya faida kuch ko kam aur nuksaan kuch ko jyada hua? Aakhir kyu hamne, hum sab ne uski zarurat ya gair zarurat ko samjha ? ya nhi samjha? Aakhir kyu? Aakhir kyu?

Monday, 21 November 2011

Neo Neutralism


“Neo Neutralism”
Now we are facing the dilemmas of “new neutralism” in which neutral behaviour is the product of several and compartmentalised ideas, ranging from one extreme to another. It is nothing but a distinct amalgamation of several ideologies. These ideologies get it chances to surface in conducive atmosphere. It becomes responsive in susceptible condition. Is it end of ideology or just new avatar of distinct and self-indulging dogmas? Empirical observations and realist approach appears to favour latter.

Sunday, 20 November 2011

Freedom and Regulation of Media


Freedom and Regulation of Media
Meraj Ahmad
Date: 21.11.11
Thank to the present leadership of Chair of PCI. He rightly pointed out and initiated debate about role of media. In the country like ours, media is expected to play a very meaningful role. Socio-Economic data are known to all of us, reflects how far we are behind from even other contemporary developing economies. Justice M. Katju highlighted the role of media in the present juncture of time as we moving from agrarian economy to industrial economy, a "very agonizing period". Media must be regulated externally like other democracy, pleas of unfettered freedom of speech is not desirable. It should be more sensitive to public cause, and should not only highlight the socio-economic problems of our country but also initiate intellectual debate, especially in “visual media”.
Presently, new crops of media channels, as many wish to call it, are not in fact media channel in true sense. Sad truism is that these channels serve the business and entertainment houses because their very survival is depending on those monetary and political backing. These channels have no character of "press", as most of time they are broadcasting unnecessary "news". They lie in between. Between the "entertainment" and "news". Between “good” and “bad” news. This is the genesis of the problem. And if these media channels are having problems with the notion and dictas of what should be broadcasted or what not, they must be desist from calling themselves as media or press. Would it be better to tag as semi-media or semi-entertainment channel? This middle position creates regulatory problems- about agency, law and authority, and of course, about genuine democracy.

The real question is, “why there is need to demarcate between news channel and entertainment channel?” How is it possible? Whether through law and institutional mechanisms? How will it work? Who will determine the "content" of news? Will it not be autocratic, and imposition of particular values and notions? The best solution seems lies in bringing in appropriate demarcation and certification of channels.

So far electronic media has been self-regulatory, results of which are in front of all of us. Middle character creates problem of accountability and responsibility, in the absence of clear cut demarcation. Although water tight compartmentalization is neither desirable nor possible, major character may be defined (as per coverage). For example, if electronic media comes under the purview of PCI, after it broader mandate, it could be given proper certificate of its real identity and character, so that accountability and responsibility could be determined. 
The rationale for such certification is that it is very difficult to distinguish what is public or private. If the notion is imposed about “content”, there could be huge hue and cry. The biggest problem is how to iron out the terrain of diverse content, and at the same time protect the freedom of speech.
 Every people must have right to information, an unfettered flow of information. He/ She should know and be free what he would wish to watch or see. Overdose of entertainment in the name of news is a social crime. Posing the whole debate of media regulation in this context provides very useful insight and justification for external regulation.
The issue of fake and irresponsible news should also be taken into account under the proposed regime, so that guilty may be booked, for fine and imprisonment both. The real fact appears that these so called media/ news channels are not reflecting the mood of common middle class people (to be entertained in such a way), but are shaping it, to divert attention from real democratic issues like poverty, health, employment etc. Therefore, time has come for identification, in turn, certification of "real mass media", required to strengthen the constitutional values and to sustain and cherish democratic institutions.
I am agreeing that self-regulation is better than external regulation at individual level. But the real question is, “how to ensure self-regulation in democratic set-up?” if any entity is not abiding by the values of “self-regulation”, what is the remedy available to public at large? The notion of self-regulation may work well in non-democratic set-up but as far as democracy is concerned, external public regulation through representative institutions is essential. Whether all other democratic institutions viz. Parliament, Executive and Judiciary should be left for self-regulation? I think, no. Regulation should not be misunderstood as an autocratic harassment. Regulation is required on sustainable basis.


With all my sincerity and respect I would like to be disagreeing to those who are against external regulation. I am very much convinced that time has come for effective external regulation for media, esp. visual media, as it affects more. Proper regulation comes from awareness. This is true for all public institutions. This has been the ideal duty of press and media. The present media is completely averse of it. I am also very much agree that responsibility should be shared. But in this respect, media is NOT sharing it real duty, required for prosperity and happiness. Of course Parliament and judiciary is bound by self-regulation, but it must also be remembered at the same time that there so many "external" and "internal" regulatory structures, one of them WAS media. I must also say that external regulation of media is absolute necessity.




Meraj Ahmad









*Views are welcome

Freedom and Regulation of Press